Different Strokes

November 30, 2011
Posted by Michael Jeh on 11/30/2011 in Michael Jeh
To be or not to be? Australian, that is

Ricky Ponting: Should he go gracefully or keep fighting for his spot? © AFP

With the Gabba Test just a day away, it’s traditionally the time when Australian cricket fans turn their minds away from their winter football passions and begin a summer of cricket analysis, dissecting the fortunes of the national cricket team at backyard bbq’s. What I’ve been hearing recently is a genuine ‘identity crisis’ in some senses. What does the baggy green stand for? Is it a highly prized reward for the best 11 cricketers in the land? Is it a national institution? Does the right to wear the cap belong to a great player or has the Australian Way always been about the team superseding the individual, regardless of his ‘greatness’?

Let’s start with the Ricky Ponting dilemma; one of the all-time greats nearing the end of an illustrious career. Should he go gracefully or keep fighting for his spot? Monitoring talkback radio, internet blogs and sports magazine shows on TV, I sensed a strong push towards giving him the push. It’s almost a back-handed compliment to Ponting in that the masses don’t want to see him get to the point where he is dropped on form. They want to remember their champion batsman as exactly that – a magnificent warrior who walked off the stage with people still wishing he had one more innings left in him.

I’m in two schools about Ponting’s situation. One part of me admires the fact that he seems to just love playing cricket and wants to keep doing it for as long as he can. Good on him if that is his motivation for refusing to hang up his boots. If he still genuinely loves strapping on the pads and walking out to bat, I admire him for refusing to let anyone else’s agenda overrule his sheer love for the game. It will be interesting to see if that love only extends to playing for Australia or whether he might eventually choose to drop down a level and play Shield cricket. After all, there are talented youngsters in Tasmania too who will benefit from having a player of his calibre in the dressing room.

Is it cricket that he loves or cricket for Australia? I can relate to his sheer love of the game. When I stopped playing at my highest level, there was no question that I would hang up my boots. I’ve continued to slip down the grades to where some would argue I rightfully belong. I simply love playing cricket and I realise I’ll be retired a long time so I’m going to keep playing at any level until the body physically refuses to co-operate. It doesn’t particularly worry me that I’m not scoring big hundreds or bowling at the same speeds. For me, it’s not about how good I am but how much I genuinely love the game. Z Grade here I come. Is Ponting of the same ilk I wonder?

The other part of me wonders why such a great player would want to carry on when he hears all the carping? Does he really want to push his luck to the point where he meets his fate on the end of a sword? It might seem undignified to some people but there’s also a certain element of noble warrior mentality in that attitude. He fought his way into the team and he’ll keep fighting to his last breath, accepting the coup de grace in that inevitably brave way that the old alpha male lion finally walks away from his pride of lionesses.

Does Ponting have a definite date or statistical figure in mind or is he just going to let Nature have her way and keep fighting until he is usurped? I’m not brave enough to predict that the runs will dry up this summer for Ponting. He is too good a player (even still) and I don’t rate the quality of the opposition bowling attacks this summer. New Zealand are brave as always but their fast-bowling attack lacks venom. India are a fabulous batting unit but I don’t their quicks will pose any significant threat on Australian pitches, especially if they lose Ishant Sharma to the inevitable injury halfway through the tour. So we’re not going to necessarily be able to judge Ponting on form alone this summer because he will most probably peel off a big score at some point. Which then begs the question…what will be the trigger for his retirement? Or is he waiting for the trigger?

The other big issue has been the Mickey Arthur saga. I’ve heard a lot of people who are appalled that a non-Australian is coaching our cricket team. I must confess that I don’t share their horror. It’s a professional game and national pride is no longer what it used to be. Cricket Australia concede as much when they allow (force?) players to fulfill IPL commitments ahead of Test-match preparations. So what’s the problem with choosing the best man for the job, irrespective of his passport? Australian coaches have been coaching foreign teams and we have no such uneasiness when that happens so why is our national team so special? Some of our biggest and most iconic national corporate brands are headed up by foreigners. Qantas, the so-called Australian airline, has an Irishman in charge. One of our biggest mining companies, BHP Billiton has a South African-born chap extracting Australian minerals from the ground and selling it to China and India. So what’s so special about the Australian cricket team? Some of our greatest cricketers in recent times have walked away from the national side and then continued to plunder riches in the IPL. Clearly they still love playing the game but only when there’s big money involved. Otherwise, why not keep playing Shield cricket or grade cricket and pass on the legacy?

It promises to be a summer of utter contrast. The dawn of new careers and the end of some great ones. I’m going to savour watching Sachin Tendulkar, Rahul Dravid, Virender Sehwag and VVS Laxman for the last time on Australian soil. They have all scored great hundreds in this country and despite their age, I think that the Australian bowling attack will still allow them to give us one last show. It’s a rare time when a few of the all-time batting greats will all be playing in the twilight of their careers so it’s a wonderful opportunity to contrast their styles and methods. Mind you, the way Dravid and Tendulkar keep churning out the runs, maybe I’m writing their epitaph a bit too soon!

Comments (11)
Posted by: Gizza at November 30, 2011 11:13 PM

Great article but on current form you should omit the "and Tendulkar" from the last sentence of the article.

Posted by: Pranesh, at December 1, 2011 3:41 AM

@Gizza : you've been watching/following india matches lately?

Posted by: Kothandaram at December 1, 2011 9:54 AM

Wonderful piece. there is too much being made about having a foreigner as the Aussie coach...
the forthcoming India-Aus series Down Under should be interesting. the big three of Indian batting will pose questions to the young Aussie attack.

Posted by: Daison at December 1, 2011 12:06 PM

I dont agree you suggesting that "even if Ponting score big against New Zealand and India, it wont be true reflection of his batting form". Well, if he score big in these series, the monkey should be off his back the same way it got there when he didnt score. Though I dont like Ponting's so called "fighting spirit" (where as it should have been sportsman spirit), he is one great batsman who can score a hundren even on an "off-day". If Cricket Australia force him to retire its Australia's loss as there are not many waiting on the sidelines at the moment anyway.

Posted by: Gizza at December 2, 2011 8:03 AM

@Pranesh, yes I have and he hasn't made a century in quite a while now. Ever since the World Cup, Tendulkar hasn't been "churning out the runs". That's 6 Test Matches and quite a few One-dayers where he has missed out.

Posted by: Jslater at December 2, 2011 7:09 PM

@Gizza rewind 2007-08. Tendulkar again had an average year in 2007.
I am laughing , you know you are writing him off before the series. He has a 40+ in 2011, it was around 38 in 2007(before Aus series. Ponting avg.20 before NZ test, much lesser than Tendulkar.

Posted by: Jason Gizzepie at December 2, 2011 10:38 PM

Dravid, Tendulkar, and Laxman may be going for the last time to Australia, but where did Sehwag come from? He's still going to be around till the next world cup atleast, he's only just turned 33. Wow. Seriously, where did Sehwag come from?

Posted by: LOL at December 3, 2011 11:53 AM

Great, lets turn this comments thread into one about the Indian team.

I think Punter likes playing for Australia and earning top dollar to do it. Who can blame him for that? I can't imagine playing state cricket would interest him at all. He appears to only do it when he absolutely has to.

The younger players aren't putting enough pressure on him to move along, though running them out is as good a way to ensure that as any. I hope Usman loses enough awe of him to roar 'No' next time.

Posted by: RC at December 3, 2011 11:53 PM

I am hoping that Ponting turns his attention to golf when he finally goes. I followed him for 13 holes at a celebrity pro-am and the little dude is a natural born smacker of the ball. Short game was good too. He could be Australia's answer to Dion Sanders and have 2 sporting careers in the one lifetime, though not overlapping like the great Neon's.

Regarding Mickey Arthur, I'm with you. The coach could be an Eskimo for all I care, as long as he knows what he's doing and can get the best out of his players. Mickey strikes me as a very measured, intelligent bloke and I think he was the right choice. I'm not certain exactly who else had their hat in the ring, but they would all be hard pressed to bring more credentials to the table than Mickey.

Finally, re the Indian's this summer. I'm looking forward to my last live view of Scahin and VVS. I don't think we'll see either of them in tests out here again, so it will be nice to see them one last time. They've both been magnificent.

Posted by: Gizza at December 4, 2011 11:43 AM

@Jslater, when did I say I was writing Tendulkar off? I merely said Tendulkar is in bad form at the moment which he is. Compare the number of runs and hundreds made by Dravid and Tendulkar in their last 15 innings. I didn't say anything about his entire career just how he is batting at the moment.

That aside, I think he will score one century in the tour of Australia probably in Sydney. I dunno why you mentioned Ponting. I didn't say Ponting is in good form either. I think he won't make a ton this entire summer (including the second test against NZ but that's his best chance in front of his crowd).

For India's sake, Dravid, Laxman, Sehwag and Kohli all have the potential to score multiple centuries. Australia will rely on Hussey, Watson (if fit), to a lesser extent Clarke, and I will predict at least one of Warner or Khawaja will shine with the bat.

Posted by: Nishant at December 4, 2011 3:18 PM

Lol. That Sehwag thing came out of nowhere! Surely he has some more time!

But barring that, well said. I wish I could argue vociferously that our bowlers will set the Australian pitches on fire, but I really don't know yet. The youngsters HAVE looked really good though, and that is on Indian pitches. So I'm hoping they will do some good things in Australia!

Unfortunately, as an Indian, I can't summon up the due respect for Ponting. He has considerable bad blood with the Indian fans. So I shall keep shut on that point.

Name: Email Address:
Comments: characters left
Shanaka Amarasinghe
Shanaka Amarasinghe Shanaka Amarasinghe Possessing the best disguised googly in Sri Lanka (because no one has ever really seen it), Shanaka is the finest legspinner to never have played top-level cricket. He is a popular cricket analyst and host of The Score, the No. 1-rated, if slightly infamous, sports show on radio in Sri Lanka. While in England playing rugby, he earned his LLM at King’s College and is a lawyer by training if not inclination. He is also an actor, a journalist, a writer, and thinks he is a comedian.
Mike Holmans
Mike HolmansMike Holmans, a database consultant by profession, has spent thirty summers (and a few winters) going to the cricket. Brought up in one and working in the other, his dearest wish is for a season to end with Yorkshire winning the county championship by beating runners-up Middlesex by one wicket with five minutes to go. If it’s also a summer when England win the Ashes, so much the better.
Michael Jeh
Michael JehMichael Jeh Born in Colombo, educated at Oxford and now living in Brisbane, Michael Jeh (Fox) is a cricket lover with a global perspective on the game. An Oxford Blue who played first-class cricket, he is a Playing Member of the MCC and still plays grade cricket. Michael now works closely with elite athletes, and is passionate about youth intervention programmes. He still chases his boyhood dream of running a wildlife safari operation called Barefoot in Africa.
Saad Shafqat
Saad ShafqatSaad Shafqat takes special pride that his cricket-watching life began during the three-month interval between Javed Miandad's debut Test in Lahore and Imran Khan's 12-wicket haul at Sydney. Although a practicing neurologist based in Karachi, cricket has never been far from his activities. He has co-authored Javed Miandad’s autobiography Cutting Edge and has been a contributor to Cricinfo since 2005. His regular column Reverse Swing appears fortnightly in Dawn, Pakistan’s leading English daily.
Latest News
Specials
© ESPN EMEA Ltd